5 Common Payroll Mistakes Businesses Must Avoid
Any payroll mistake affects every employee in your organization, and no employee can afford to make it. The conversation in the break room about an employee not getting paid on time is a clear sign of the problem. Meanwhile, a quiet reporting error can sit hidden for a year until an auditor finds it.
Key Takeaways
- The five mistakes are misclassifying employees, missing deadlines, getting taxes and reporting wrong, recording hours wrong, paying outside payroll, and keeping bad books.
- Record keeping usually sits at the core of most of the other issues. Begin addressing record keeping errors first.
- Federal rules set the floor. Most states ask for more, so check yours.
- A short, monthly check catches most errors.
- Payroll eats most small businesses’ weeks. If it eats yours, outsource it to a company that runs it every day.
We’ve spent a long time in payroll and record keeping. Most errors come from the busy owner, not the careless one. Most owners start their business to serve customers, not to learn payroll law. Eventually, payroll becomes part of the job, and the law gets more demanding.
The five payroll mistakes we talk about later in the post are the major ones we have seen. Each of the errors comes with a simple, immediate solution. Towards the end, you will find a short, monthly check you can do immediately.
Why Small Payroll Errors Grow Fast
Payroll repeats. You run it every week or every two weeks. So one wrong setting does not cause one wrong check. It causes dozens.
Let’s say a company pays 12 employees twice a month. One mistake on a tax setting impacts 288 paychecks. Every one of those has to be fixed. It only takes a small mistake to create a large problem.
Mistake 1: Misclassifying Employees
Nothing causes more trouble than misclassifying employees. The name you give someone determines what you owe. Employees are entitled to minimum wage and overtime. You withhold taxes from their pay and pay payroll taxes on their wages. Independent contractors don’t receive either. Choose the wrong name, and you could owe back wages, back taxes, and penalties all at once.
Let’s look at a made-up situation. A shop hires a part-time designer and contracts her to work set hours each week. The designer uses the shop’s tools and takes orders from the shop owner. The shop pays no overtime and withholds no tax. Agencies will look to see how much control a business has over someone’s work and may decide the designer was an employee. Now, the shop owes the back pay and penalties, in addition to the taxes that they didn’t withhold.
Exempt and non-exempt employees are divided in the same way. Non-exempt employees are entitled to overtime pay if they work past 40 hours in a week. Some states count by the day instead of hours. Exempt employees aren’t entitled to overtime pay unless their job and pay meet the legal requirements for exemption. A job title proves nothing. Someone called a “manager” who spends the day stocking shelves may still be non-exempt.
How To Avoid It
When hiring employees, make sure you clarify their classification status. After hiring, if an employee’s job function changes, you should reclassify them. For employees whose classification status is uncertain, document the rationale behind their current classification. If a case feels very close, ask a tax pro before the first paycheck, not after the first audit.
Mistake 2: Missing Payment Deadlines
Payroll has many moving parts, so you can miss payroll deadlines. The cost of that slip happens quickly. Employees lose faith in you if you give them a paycheck late. Paying employees late is also a trust issue with the state. Some states determine how often you pay employees. Missed tax deadlines hurt even more. Late deposits and filings bring penalties and interest. The bill grows the longer the amount sits unpaid.
Say a made-up payroll tax deposit is due on a Friday. The only person who does it is out sick. No one else knows the login. It gets done the next week, and the company pays a penalty. A backup would have solved the whole problem.
How To Avoid It
Put every pay date, deposit date, and filing date on one calendar. Add a reminder a few days in advance. Name a primary person who owns the calendar and a backup. Check your state’s pay frequency rule once a year, since those rules change.
Mistake 3: Misapplying Taxes and Reporting Pay Wrong
Salary, bonuses, and overtime need to go in your records and on your IRS reports. People usually forget the small stuff. Gift cards and other similar incentives are taxable pay. The IRS treats a gift card like cash, however small. If you don’t report it, you could face a penalty.
Here’s a made-up example. The manager gives the top 5 sales reps a $50 gift card. No one tells payroll. That’s $250 of pay that never reached the records. At year end, the wage reports are wrong.
The other slips look the same. Some businesses apply tax credits wrong, or not at all. Other businesses code income wrong or apply fringe benefits wrong. None of these shout at the time. They show up at filing, when fixing them costs far more.
How To Avoid It
Create a list of all types of pay and perks you provide. Ask how each one is taxed. Have a tax professional review the list every year. Our tax preparation services cover these issues for businesses that want a second pair of eyes.
Mistake 4: Recording Hours Wrong and Paying Outside Payroll
These two mistakes share the same root. Pay no longer reflects reality.
First, let’s look at hours. Minor mistakes in time recordings accumulate and can significantly impact an employee’s daily and overtime pay. Rounding time in an employee’s favor is okay. However, look out for rounding that always goes against an employee. Say a made-up time clock rounds every shift down by seven minutes. That is 35 minutes a week. Over a year, it adds up to close to 29 hours of unpaid work. Rounding is only fair when it averages out. Also watch for breaks nobody logged and for edits made after a manager approved the timesheet.
Now let’s look at pay that escapes payroll. There are many reasons that pay or compensation escapes payroll (i.e., cash payments, bonuses, reimbursements, expenses, etc.). While those actions may seem harmless, they are not. That habit leaves unreported pay, missing taxes, and a record that doesn’t tell the truth.
How To Avoid It
Have a one-time system. Have all hours approved by a manager before each pay run. Have all payments, bonuses, and reimbursements run through payroll. Have a written policy approved by your tax professional for anything that escapes payroll.
Mistake 5: Keeping Weak Records
An incomplete paper trail can lead to serious problems during an audit. Many small businesses assume their software remembers everything. Then they spend hours trying to rebuild months of history.
How To Avoid It
We advise tracking every transaction for every employee. We mean everything, including promotions, pay changes, overtime, allowances, deductions, bonuses, and company contributions. Keep one file for each employee and include the following information in that file:
- The employee’s pay rate and any changes to the pay rate
- Hours worked and pay date for each
- Deductions and company contributions
- Tax forms
- A note as to the reason for the classification
- Signed offer letters and any role change letters
Under the FLSA, employers must retain payroll records for at least 3 years. The IRS generally requires employers to retain employment tax records for at least 4 years. Many states require a longer retention period. Ask your tax professional which period applies to you.
Why Records Come First
What we’ve seen with the four mistakes above is that a common thread is a lack of records for employees. Without this information, you’re guessing how to classify your employees, unsure of the dates in your various tools, and therefore missing deadlines. Without a record of the types of pay you give employees, you may face tax issues. And without good records on hours, you’ll find yourself with overtime issues.
Good records for your employees will help you avoid these four mistakes and prepare for an audit. But it’s a lot of work, and many small business owners don’t have the time to do it. This is why working with a bookkeeper to make sure that you have your books and payroll in sync is a great idea. That is the idea behind our small business accounting work.
A Simple Monthly Payroll Check
This process doesn’t have to be complicated. At the end of the month, take an hour and do the following.
Most mistakes will occur during step 1 and step 4. If you catch these mistakes during the month that they happen, you can fix them in minutes. But when you find them a year later, you’ll be spending weeks trying to fix them.
When To Hand Payroll To Someone Else
Some businesses can’t carry a full payroll process in-house. If that sounds like you, think about outsourcing. Pick a small accounting firm with the right skills and a clear track record. Ask any firm how it handles classification, deadlines, and records. Then ask to see how it reports back to you. Our payroll management service is built for small businesses that want payroll done right without hiring a full team.
Final Thoughts
Payroll never feels urgent until something goes wrong. Classify people with care. Keep one calendar. Know how every kind of pay is taxed. Match the books to the real hours. Keep records you could hand to an auditor tomorrow. Do those five things, and payroll goes back to being the quiet department it should be.
If you want help, we’re ready. Schedule a call and we’ll talk through where your payroll stands today.